A quick heads up if you are attempting to discern the VALUE difference between #654 and #655. Both stamps are worth less than 50¢ used and unused no more than a couple of dollars. Therefore you might not consider the identification process below useful to you.
A great choice would be any of the lower stamp denominations from the 1938 president series shown above . The used stamps have negligible value, less that an nickel, so not much harm done by cutting them up. However I would not use the dollar values of this series as they do have some value.
Cut a square out of each corner as shown above, make sure you cut into the design. I chose a used one cent stamp, but any used lower denomination from the 1938 series would do.
Once you have followed the visual guide above, click the image above that most resembles your Edison stamp.