1c -Green or gray green
Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #531 - 1919
Ebay prices are for pairs
NY auction house prices are for plate blocks of six
Graded prices are for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $10-$40 (LP) - $5 $2 - -
Spring 2006 $10 - - - $200 -
Fall 2006 $7-$12 - $3-$6 - - -
Spring 2007 $23-$26 (LP) - $9 $12 - -
Fall 2007 $14-$20 (LP) - $6 $8 - -
Spring 2008 $15-$20 (LP) - - - $200 -
Fall 2008 $15-$16 (LP) - - $5 - -
Spring 2009 $18 (LP) - $12 - - -
Fall 2009 - - - $7 - -
Spring 2010 $5-$40 (LP) - $26 (LP) - - -
Fall 2010 $40 (LP) - $10 - - -
Spring 2011 $14 - $22 (LP) $10 - -
$85 100J - - - -
Fall 2011 $14-$21 (LP) - - $6-$10 - -
2012 $12-$18 (LP) - $15 (LP) - - -
$65 95 - - - -
2013 - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - -


2c - Rose - Type IV
Top line of the toga is broken, the first and last lines of shading in
the toga button form a "D" and reversed "D", the line of
color in the left "2" is usually broken or thin.

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #532 - 1920
Ebay prices are for pairs
NY auction house prices are for plate blocks of six

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $30-$55 $25 $15-$25 - -
Spring 2006 $40-$50 - - $375 -
Fall 2006 $45-$80 - $15-$23 $240 (pair) 100
Spring 2007 $27-$40 $11 - - -
Fall 2007 $45 - - - -
Spring 2008 $75 (LP) - - $725 -
Fall 2008 $60 - - $140 95J
- - - $250 (single) 100
Spring 2009 $80 (LP) $55 (LP) - $300-$400 (single) 100J
Fall 2009 - - - - -
Spring 2010 $85 (LP) - - $50 95
Fall 2010 $45 $22 - - -
Spring 2011 - $35 (LP) - $200 98J
Fall 2011 - $14-$40 (LP) - $280 (single) 100
2012 $60-$90 - $125 $100 (single) 95
- - - $475 (single) 100
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

prices are for singles

 
  MNH MH Used
Spring 2010 $26-$45 $20 -
Fall 2010 $45-$55 $9-$20 $35-$75
Spring 2011 $50 $21 -
Fall 2011 $35 $23-$30 $14-$16
2012 $50-$70 $16-$30 %14-$21
2013 - - -
2014 - - -
2015 - - -
2016 - - -
2017 - - -
2018 - - -

Scotts 532 Wilson Perf
Scott #532
Private Perforation
"This roulette was created by Pittsburgh banker J.H. Wilson when a loan that had
been secured with a quantity of imperf U.S. stamps, defaulted. Wilson applied the roulette
so that he could recoup some of his loss by selling the stamps to local businesses
"
Photo courtesy of Bennet Stamps


2c -Carmine - Type V
Top line of the toga is complete, there are five vertical lines of
shading in the toga button, the line of color in the
left "2" is usually broken or thin.

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #533 - 1920
Ebay prices are for pairs
NY auction house prices are for plate blocks of six

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $200 - - - -
Spring 2006 $325 - - $290-$950 -
Fall 2006 - - - - -
Spring 2007 - - - - -
Fall 2007 - - - - -
Spring 2008 - - $160 $250 -
Fall 2008 - $105 - $225 -
Spring 2009 - - - - -
Fall 2009 - - - - -
Spring 2010 $310 - - - -
Fall 2010 $150 - - - -
Spring 2011 - - - - -
Fall 2011 $200 - - - -
2012 $175 $40 - - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

Prices for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH Graded Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 - - $60-$75 - $60 $300 -
Spring 2006 - - $80 - $65 $205-$210 -
Fall 2006 - 85 $195 85 - - -
Spring 2007 $235 - $65-$100 - $70 - -
Fall 2007 $150-$210 - - - $35 $375 98
Spring 2008 $160 - $45 - - - -
Fall 2008 $115-$175 - $85 - $35-$40 $135 90
- - - - - $170 95
- - - - - $240 98
Spring 2009 $105-$110 - $135 - - $240 98
Fall 2009 - - - - $40 - -
$220 95 - - - - -
Spring 2010 $175 - - - $26-$70 - -
Fall 2010 $320 - $70 - $60 - -
Spring 2011 $175 - $80-$145 - $35-$60 - -
- - - - - - -
Fall 2011 $95-$200 - $45 - $27-$115 - -
$220 95 - - - - -
2012 $60-$175 - $85 - $28-$55 $225 95
- - - - - $375 98J
2013 - - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - - -



2c - or carmine rose - Type Va
As type V, except that the third row of dots from the bottom,
on the shading of the nose, has four dots instead of six.

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #534 - 1920
Ebay prices are for pairs
NY auction house prices are for plate blocks of six
  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Spring 2006 $20 $11 $45 $160 -
Fall 2006 $17-$29 - - - -
Spring 2007 $19-$75 (LP) $9-$10 $25 - -
Fall 2007 $24 - - - -
Spring 2008 $21 - $8 $250 -
Fall 2008 $22 $14 - - -
Spring 2009 $16-$27 (LP) - $15 - -
Fall 2009 - $9-$11 - $100 -
Spring 2010 $40 (LP) $12 - - -
Fall 2010 $40 (LP) - - - -
Spring 2011 - $40 (LP) - - -
Fall 2011 $17-$20 - - - -
2012 $50 $20-$25 - - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

Prices for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $16-$22 - $5-$10 - - -
Spring 2006 $17-$20 - $7 - - -
Fall 2006 $15 - $7 - - -
Spring 2007 $10-$26 - - - - -
Fall 2007 $15 - $9 $7 - -
Spring 2008 $17 - $23 - - -
Fall 2008 $17-$19 - $3-$11 $11 $135 100
- - - - $200 100J
Spring 2009 $11-$18 - $7-$9 - $145 100
Fall 2009 $25 - $4-$9 $2 - -
Spring 2010 $16-$25 - $8-$11 - - -
Fall 2010 $14-$22 - $10 - - -
Spring 2011 $16-$45 - $8-$12 $3-$6 - -
Fall 2011 $13-$40 - $6-$13 $4-$12 - -
2012 $13-$35 - $19 - - -
$9-$21 90 $5-$15 $4-$15 - -
2013 - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - -



2c - Carmine - Type VI
As type V, except that the line of color in the left two is very heavy

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #534A - 1920
Prices for pairs

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Spring 2006 - - - $460 -
Fall 2006 - - - - -
Spring 2007 $75 $45 - - -
Fall 2007 - - - - -
Spring 2008 $110-$115 $50 - $500 -
Fall 2008 - - - - -
Spring 2009 - - - - -
Fall 2009 - - - $140 -
Spring 2010 - $55 - - -
Fall 2010 $70 - - - -
Spring 2011 $105-$120 $21-$27 - - -
Fall 2011 $75 - $40 - -
2012 $90 $25-$50 (LP) $14 - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

Prices for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $35-$90 $20 $8 - -
Spring 2006 $60-$90 $20-$28 - - -
Fall 2006 - - - - -
Spring 2007 $60-$85 $25-$40 - - -
Fall 2007 $45-$50 $30 $21-$22 - -
Spring 2008 $60 $40-$45 - - -
Fall 2008 $35-$60 $20-$28 - $115 95
Spring 2009 $40-$65 $30 $17 - -
Fall 2009 - $22-$30 - - -
Spring 2010 $60-$75 $20-$30 $25 - -
Fall 2010 $40-$65 $29 $40 - -
Spring 2011 $40-$60 - - - -
Fall 2011 $40-$70 $30-$40 $20 - -
2012 $45-$100 $23-$65 $15-$35 - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -


2c - Carmine- Type VII
As type V, except that there is an additional row of dots to the upper lip,

additional dots in the hair have been added and the
line of color in the left two is usually continuous.

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #534B - 1920

Prices for CERTIFICATED pairs
Beware of trimmed 528B made to look like 534B

  NY Auction Houses
  MH Used MNH Graded Used Graded
Fall 2005 - - $4,000 - - -
Spring 2006 - - $7,000 - - -
Fall 2006 - - $4,250 (LP) - - -
Spring 2007 - - - - - -
Fall 2007 - - - - - -
Spring 2008 - - $6,000 - - -
Fall 2008 - - - - - -
Spring 2009 - - $4,750 - - -
Fall 2009 - - - - - -
Spring 2010 - - $5,500 - - -
Fall 2010 - - - - - -
Spring 2011 - - $4,250 95 - -
Fall 2011 - - $3,500-$4,000 - - -
2012 $3,185 (ng) (LP) - - - $3,000 -
2013 - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - -

Prices for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded MH Graded Used Graded
Fall 2005 $2,000 $200 $155 $5,500 - - - - -
Spring 2006 - - - - - - - - -
Fall 2006 - - - - - - - - -
Spring 2007 - - - - - - - - -
Fall 2007 - $160 $65 $2,800 - - - - -
Spring 2008 - - - - - - - - -
Fall 2008 - - $155 $2,700 90 $1,600 95 - -
- - - $2,500 90J $2,400 98 - -
- - - $3,500 95 - - - -
- - - $4,750 98 - - - -
Spring 2009 - - $250 $4,250 98 - - - -
Fall 2009 - - $80 - - - - - -
Spring 2010 - - - - - - - - -
Fall 2010 - - - - - - - - -
Spring 2011 - - $145 - - - - - -
Fall 2011 $1,900 - $375 - - - - $3,250 98J
2012 $2,500 - $195-$350 $3,250 95 - - - -
2013 - - - - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - - - - -


3c - Purple, light purple or deep purple - Type IV
The "P" and "O" of postage are joined. At the bottom line of the
vignette the frame line is broken, the shading lines of the toga rope
are complete and the second and fourth shading lines of the toga rope are broken.

Offset printing - Imperf - Unwatermarked - Scott #535 - 1918
Ebay prices are for pairs
NY auction house prices are for plate blocks of six

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $12-$40 (LP) $8 - - -
Spring 2006 $15-$25 (LP) $10 - - -
Fall 2006 - - - - -
Spring 2007 $11-$40 (LP) $7 - - -
Fall 2007 $8 - - - -
Spring 2008 - $11 - $150 -
Fall 2008 - $10 $2 - -
Spring 2009 $10-$16 - - - -
Fall 2009 $8 $8 $3 - -
Spring 2010 $20-$27 (LP) $9 - - -
Fall 2010 $12-$35 (LP) - - - -
Spring 2011 - $7 - - -
Fall 2011 $17-$22 (LP) $22 - - -
2012 $11-$21 $17-$19 (LP) $14 - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

Prices for singles

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH MH Graded Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $10-$35 $4-$6 - - - -
Spring 2006 $12-$29 $9 - - - -
Fall 2006 $8-$12 - - - - -
Spring 2007 $12-$45 $8 - $23 - -
Fall 2007 $5-$12 $4-$6 - $8 - -
Spring 2008 $24-$30 $5-$11 - $2 - -
Fall 2008 $6-$13 $5 - $1-$5 $225 100
Spring 2009 $6-$15 $1-$4 - $3-$6 $230 100J
Fall 2009 $5-$10 $3-$5 - $2 $100 100J
Spring 2010 $6-$12 $3 - $3-$4 - -
Fall 2010 $4-$8 $4-$7 - $2 - -
Spring 2011 $12 $4-$10 - $4 - -
Fall 2011 $8-$14 $3-$7 - - - -
2012 $4-$15 $2-$12 - $2-$6 - -
- $12 98 - - -
2013 - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - -



3c - Purple, light purple or deep purple - Type IV
Offset printing - Imperf
Double Impression
Unwatermarked - Scott #535a - 1918

Fall 2009 Auction - MNH - $225


1c - Gray green
Offset printing - Perf. 12 ½
Unwatermarked - Scott #536 - 1919

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH Used MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $15-$18 - $2-$8 - - -
Spring 2006 $22-$26 - $7-$16 - $220 90J
Fall 2006 - - $3-$9 $8 $600 95
- - - - $1,400 98J
Spring 2007 $15-$100 - $4-$11 - - -
Fall 2007 $12-$19 - $4-$7 - $150-$210 90J
- - - - $1,300 98
Spring 2008 $14-$18 - $3 $30 - -
Fall 2008 $9-$19 - $3-$7 - $325 95
- - - - $450 95J
Spring 2009 $9-$20 - $4-$5 - $190 95J
- - - - $2,600 100
Fall 2009 $6-$22 - $3-$5 $20 $90 90
Spring 2010 $9-$16 - $7-$8 $6-$7 - -
Fall 2010 $8-$26 - $4-$5 - $250 95J
Spring 2011 $15-$35 - $4-$15 - - -
$85 90 - - - -
Fall 2011 $9-$20 - $4-$20 $1 $525 98
- - - - $950 98J
2012 $7-$60 - $4-$13 $10-$21 $140 90J
$90 90 - - - -
$415 95J - - - -
2013 - - - - - -
2014 - - - - - -
2015 - - - - - -
2016 - - - - - -
2017 - - - - - -
2018 - - - - - -


1c - Gray green
Offset printing - Perf. 12 ½ - imperforate vertically
Unwatermarked - Scott #536a - 1919

  NY Auction Houses
  MH Graded
Fall 2010 $650 -
Spring 2011 - -
- -
Fall 2011 $1,200 -
2012 $1,100 -
2013 - -
2014 - -
2015 - -
2016 - -
2017 - -
2018 - -


3c - Violet
100,000,000 - Flat plate - Perf. 11 - Unwatermarked - Scott #537 - 1919

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH MNH Graded
Fall 2005 $8-$35 - $2-$4 - -
Spring 2006 $7-$10 - $1-$4 $2,300 98J
Fall 2006 $8-$12 - $1-$3 $1,100 98J
Spring 2007 $5-$70 - $2-$3 - -
Fall 2007 $3-$8 - $1-$2 $650 98J
- - - $4,500 100
Spring 2008 $3-$20 - $1-$4 $220 95
$50 90 - - -
Fall 2008 $4-$10 - $1-$2 $100 95
- - - $160 95J
- - - $325 98
- - - $850 98J
Spring 2009 $5-$12 - $1-$4 $125 95J
- - - $400 98J
- - - $1,200 100
Fall 2009 $3-$10 - $1-$2 $115 90
Spring 2010 $4-$30 - $1-$2 $450 98J
Fall 2010 $8-$17 - - $2,500 100J
$315 98J $1-$4 - -
Spring 2011 $3-$30 - $2-$8 - -
Fall 2011 $4-$15 - $2-$3 - -
2012 $3-$40 - $1-$4 $80 95
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -

Used examples are worth less than $1


3c - Deep red violet
Flat plate - Perf. 11 - Unwatermarked - Scott #537a - 1919
Fall 2011 Auction MH $650
Fall 2010 Auction - Used $2,000


3c - Light reddish violet
Flat plate - Perf. 11 - Unwatermarked - Scott #537b - 1919


3c - Red violet
Flat plate - Perf. 11 - Unwatermarked - Scott #537c - 1919

  NY Auction Houses
  MNH Graded MH MNH Graded
2011 - - - $525 90J
2012 - - - - -
2013 - - - - -
2014 - - - - -
2015 - - - - -
2016 - - - - -
2017 - - - - -
2018 - - - - -


1c - Green or gray green
Private Perforation
Schermack Type III
Scott #531 - 1919


2c - Carmine Rose
Private Perforation
Schermack Type III
Scott #532 - 1919


2c - Carmine Rose
Private Perforation
J. Hull Wilson
Scott #532 - 1919


2c - Carmine
Private Per.oration
Schermack Type III
Scott #533 - 1919


2c - Carmine
Private Perforation
Schermack Type III
Scott #534A - 1919


2c - Carmine
Private Perforation
Schermack Type VII
Scott #534B - 1919